• HOME
  • CRUELTY FREE RESOURCES
    • Cruelty Free Beauty Brands
    • Cruelty Free Brands at Sephora
    • Cruelty Free Questions to Ask Brands
    • News
  • About
    • About My Beauty Bunny
    • Privacy Policy & Legal
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube

My Beauty Bunny - Cruelty Free Lifestyle Blog

  • Hair
  • Health
  • Lifestyle
  • Makeup
  • Misc
    • Budget
    • Dupes
    • Fashion
    • Giveaways
    • Leaping Bunny
    • Men
  • Nails
  • News
  • Pets
  • Skin
    • Body
    • Acne-prone
    • Combination Skin
    • Dry Skin
    • Oily Skin
    • Salons
  • Travel
  • Vegan

Stay up to date with all our latest posts!

You are here: Home / Makeup / How to Find the Perfect Red Lipstick

How to Find the Perfect Red Lipstick

in Makeup on 12/30/13

Tonight’s the night; you have a hot date, and are looking to rock a sultry red lipstick. You stop by the store to find something that will drive him crazy, but you’re greeted by a thousand shades of red. Never fear, though; follow my tips to find your perfect red lipstick.

If you’re lost looking for your best shade, the first thing you need to do is check your skin tone. Are your veins in your wrist more blue based? If so, you have a cooler skin tone; however, if your veins seem more greenish or yellowish, you have a warmer skin tone.

Cool Reds:

For example, if your skin is cool-toned, the perfect shade of red for you is a blue-based red. These shades are flattering because the blue undertones contrast beautifully with the cool or pink shade of skin.

Milani Blue Based Red Lipsticks

Milani Cool Toned Red Lipsticks

Suggestions:

  • “Stalker” by Obsessive Compulsive Cosmetics – a blue based red
  • Marvelous Moxie “Call the Shots” by bareMinerals – a deep, scarlet red
  • “Bold” by Vapour Organic Beauty – a deep, cool red
  • If you’re looking for budget beauty red lippies, try Milani. The company is cruelty free and sold in drugstores nationwide. Their reds range from neutral to cool-based. Here’s my review of their red lipsticks. (Pictured above.)

Warm Reds:

For warm skintones (like mine), I suggest using an orange, brick or tomato shade of red. These shades are flattering to yellow undertones, and makes your skin look brighter and healthier. Be careful – they can make your teeth look yellow – so be sure to use a good whitening toothpaste!

Senna Venetian Red Lipstick Swatch

Boss Lady lipstick swatch

Boss Lady by Lippy Girl

Suggestions:

  • “Desire” by Nouveau Organica – the perfect brick red
  • “Venetian Red” by Senna Cosmetics – one of my favorite warm reds (pictured above)
  • “Radiate” by Obsessive Compulsive Cosmetics – a coral red
  • “Boss Lady” by Lippy Girl – a sheer, warm, moisturizing red (looks almost coral/orange on me because of my yellow undertones) – and its vegan too! (pictured above)

Neutral Reds:

If you’re in-between warm and cool, you might be able to work with a classic neutral red. If you go with a lighter hue, you risk looking washed out, minimizing the boldness red lipstick would otherwise bring.

Jane Iredale lipstick red

Jane Iredale

Suggestions:

  • “Margi” by Jane Iredale – a true red that looks a little blue on me (I have yellow undertones) (pictured above)
  • “NSFW” by Obsessive Compulsive Cosmetics – a balanced, neutral red
  • Marvelous Moxie ” Live It Up” by bareMinerals – a cherry red
  • “Siren” by Vapour Organic Beauty – a classic red

For those with grey or silver hair, a little pink provides an ice princess palette that’s perfect for occasions where you want to go against the grain.

Finally, when you’ve found the perfect lipstick in that shade of rouge, my advice is to use a lip scrub (I like Pink & Rosy by Margarita Bloom) and apply lip primer (Too Faced has a great one), which helps to retain moisture and prevents smudging. Then blot off any excess moisture. After applying a neutral lip liner, fill in the entire lip from the center outwards. Finally, seal the lipstick with a small amount of powder, and you’re set!

If you have acne or breakouts around your mouth, you may want to avoid the red lipstick until it heals. I have this problem a lot (stupid hormonal acne!) and I’ve noticed red lips can make the acne look worse.

Everyone can look their best in red lipstick; it’s just about matching your skin tone to the right shade, and applying it properly. Now that I’ve given you the perfect guide to discovering just the right red lipstick, I hope you’ll it proudly and look fabulous!

About Jen Mathews

Jen Mathews is the Chief Bunny and social media maestro for My Beauty Bunny. She is also the President of Top Tier Media, a digital marketing agency for beauty, fashion, health and lifestyle brands. Follow My Beauty Bunny on Instagram for more cruelty free goodness!

FOLLOW MY BEAUTY BUNNY ON SOCIAL:
       
 

SUBSCRIBE TO MY BEAUTY BUNNY

Get the latest on cruelty-free beauty with your FREE My Beauty Bunny newsletter!

« Youngblood Fall Makeup Picks
5 DIY Face Masks »

Comments

  1. Sugar Spun Sisters says

    December 30, 2013 at 6:18 am

    This is so helpful – I’m yet to find the “perfect” red for my skin tone!

    Faye x

    Sugar Spun Sisters – A blog about cosmetics, clothes & coeliac disease

  2. Miranda Mendoza says

    December 30, 2013 at 10:41 am

    I have a neutral skin tone so the two hardest things for me to find is a good foundaion and a good red lippy! Cool toned reds definitely look better on me, though.

  3. Jen says

    January 6, 2014 at 6:31 am

    My favorite red is Revlon’s “Really Red” – its matte finish and is a gorgeous, neutral red IMO

  4. Hergamut India says

    November 3, 2015 at 1:59 am

    Valuable post, aids to choose the perfect red-colored lipstick that suits to your skin tone.
    More: Golden rules of applying lipstick

  5. Carla_N. says

    July 28, 2017 at 4:00 pm

    MAC used to make my absolute perfect red, “Powerhouse,” which was the very first lipstick to look RED, not pink, on NW15 me.
    But then MAC discontinued Powerhouse, then I dumped them because they lost their cruelty-free status.
    I love Stila “Beso,” but I am just not a fan of liquid lipsticks.
    Anybody know of a Powerhouse dupe, in stick form?

  6. chiefbunny says

    July 30, 2017 at 12:37 pm

    I wish I knew! It looks like a slightly blue-based red from the photos online? I checked Temptalia’s site and didn’t see any dupes there either. Sorry!

What is My Beauty Bunny?

My Beauty Bunny is an award-winning, top 10, cruelty free beauty, health, and lifestyle blog. We've been publishing cruelty free beauty reviews since 2009!

Top beauty blog, My Beauty Bunny, focuses on finding the best in beauty from companies who do not test on animals. We are not a vegan blog, but we do have a vegan section.

Founder & Cruelty Free Beauty Expert, Jen Mathews, is the President of social media and marketing agency, Top Tier Media. As seen in People Style Watch, Refinery 29, HuffPost Live, Shape Magazine, Fab Fit Fun, GQ, Teen Vogue and QVC. Founder of the Beauty Blog Coalition.

LOOKING FOR SOMETHING?

SUBSCRIBE TO MY BEAUTY BUNNY

Get the latest tips and reviews with your FREE My Beauty Bunny newsletter!

FOLLOW @MYBEAUTYBUNNY ON INSTAGRAM
  • Bloglovin
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2025 · MY BEAUTY BUNNY by MLL Design + Branding Studio

  • HOME ·
  • Cruelty Free Beauty Brands
  • Privacy Policy & Legal
  • News
  • About My Beauty Bunny