• HOME
  • CRUELTY FREE RESOURCES
    • Cruelty Free Beauty Brands
    • Cruelty Free Brands at Sephora
    • Cruelty Free Questions to Ask Brands
    • News
  • About
    • About My Beauty Bunny
    • Privacy Policy & Legal
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube

My Beauty Bunny - Cruelty Free Lifestyle Blog

  • Hair
  • Health
  • Lifestyle
  • Makeup
  • Misc
    • Budget
    • Dupes
    • Fashion
    • Giveaways
    • Leaping Bunny
    • Men
  • Nails
  • News
  • Pets
  • Skin
    • Body
    • Acne-prone
    • Combination Skin
    • Dry Skin
    • Oily Skin
    • Salons
  • Travel
  • Vegan

Stay up to date with all our latest posts!

You are here: Home / Body / Makeup Wars: ALL TIME Best Cruelty Free Beauty Favorites!

Makeup Wars: ALL TIME Best Cruelty Free Beauty Favorites!

in Body, Faves, Hair, Makeup, Misc, Nails, Skin, Vegan on 09/16/13

 photo cruelty-free-drugstore-makeup.jpg

Press-Sample-Affiliate-Links
This is my FAVORITE Makeup Wars post of all time! Cruelty free – hooray! Unfortunately, it’s also one of the hardest – how can I pick my faves? There are too many! Well, here are 10 of my favorite “you must buy these immediately” kind of cruelty free products (i.e. “the ones I buy over and over again even though I get plenty of freebies from other brands and really don’t have to!”):

  1. OCC Lip Tar – Obviously a cult favorite – lip tars are amazing and there’s nothing else like them on the market! So highly pigmented and a ton of fun colors. You can also mix your own shades. (Vegan)
  2. Beautisol Summer Glow self tanner – When I’m feeling like I need to lose 10 lbs instantly, I put on my Beautisol Summer Glow self tanner – it works every time! It’s not stinky, doesn’t streak, doesn’t look orange, and it lasts about 5-6 days. Even though it’s called “dark” it’s not that dark unless you layer it over a few days, so don’t be scared to try it!  (Vegan)
  3. Tarte Maracuja Rainforest Glow Instant Matte Waterproof Body Perfector – If I need a darker glow, or I don’t have time to let my Beautisol set, I use Tarte’s body bronzer. I love that it’s waterproof and goes on evenly – just rub it in, wash your hands and you’re done!
  4. DermOrganic Leave In Shine Therapy – My must have hair product – even while traveling. I can’t be without it! It smooths hair and adds shine. Keeps away the frizzies and makes my hair look healthy and smooth. (Vegan)
  5. It Cosmetics Bye Bye Undereye – Full coverage, waterproof, yet moisturizing, concealer with anti-aging ingredients to combat dark circles while it conceals. I use it under my eyes and on acne spots as well.
  6. It Cosmetics Brow Power – Universal brow pencil (works on all hair colors). I have tried many brow pencils and powders, but I always come back to this one.
  7. Too Faced Shadow Insurance – this is the primer I use to make my shadows brighter, bolder and long-lasting. A must have.
  8. NCLA nail polish – I love this brand and its Los Angeles fashion vibe! I’m currently loving their new North of Sunset collection, but there are tons of older collections to love too!
  9. Murad Clarifying Body Spray – The whole Murad acne care line is amazing, but I am especially in love with this spray – it allows me to treat my back – an area that typically gets neglected because I can’t reach! You can spray it from any angle – even upside down!
  10. Mario Badescu Cucumber Cleansing Lotion- the perfect toner – gentle, but still does a great job of cleansing normal to oily skin. Removes pore clogging residue and disinfects skin’s surface for thoroughly clean skin to prevent future acne problems. Some may prefer witch hazel to alcohol, but try it before you make that assumption. It’s really very gentle and doesn’t dry out your skin. If you have very dry skin, try the Aloe Vera Toner or Aloe Vera Lotion.
    (NOTE: I just heard from a reader that Mario Badescu has a store in Shanghai, which would make 3rd party animal testing necessary. Until I hear otherwise, I will assume that they are NOT cruelty free. I’m very upset about this!

Whew! I’m sure I could come up with 10 more, but these are the ones that I tell all my friends and family about. The ones I use over and over, and the ones I’d highly recommend to you!

Check out what the other Makeup Wars beauty bloggers chose as their top cruelty free faves!

About Jen Mathews

Jen Mathews is the Chief Bunny and social media maestro for My Beauty Bunny. She is also the President of Top Tier Media, a digital marketing agency for beauty, fashion, health and lifestyle brands. Follow My Beauty Bunny on Instagram for more cruelty free goodness!

FOLLOW MY BEAUTY BUNNY ON SOCIAL:
       
 

SUBSCRIBE TO MY BEAUTY BUNNY

Get the latest on cruelty-free beauty with your FREE My Beauty Bunny newsletter!

« August Vegan Cuts Box
I’m Giving Away 150 Bottles of Bikini Soft Shave Oil! »

Comments

  1. sahana says

    September 16, 2013 at 1:27 am

    Such a detailed post! <3

  2. Voodoo Blonde says

    September 16, 2013 at 1:31 am

    I’ve tried OCC Lip Tars recently and their are awesome in terms of pigmentation and application, but the longetivity was a let-down for me. I think I’ll try Lime Crimes Velvetines lip colors since they’re vegan too. 🙂
    TF Shadow Insurance was a let down too, I’m using Concrete Minerals Electric Eye Primer instead, and it’s amazing (also vegan too!).

  3. Eve says

    September 16, 2013 at 3:27 am

    Great list – I find your blog so helpful! Faye still uses products from companies I have boycotted, but I am determined to have a cruelty-free make up bag and find your posts some of the most helpful on the internet!

    Eve x
    Sugar Spun Sisters – A blog about cosmetics, clothes & coeliac disease

  4. Carleen says

    September 16, 2013 at 7:31 am

    I should have added OCC lip tar to my list. I have been obsessed with it lately.

  5. jbrobeck says

    September 16, 2013 at 7:58 am

    I need to try more NCLA polishes!

  6. Christa aka Perilously Pale says

    September 16, 2013 at 8:34 am

    I totally should have included Too Faced Shadow Insurance! The BEST!

  7. Sara Highsmith happysara89 says

    September 16, 2013 at 8:44 am

    I really love Murad’s body spray when I break out on my shoulders from stress, etc. I can’t find it at sephora anymore!! Do you know where to buy it?

  8. Phyrra says

    September 16, 2013 at 11:01 am

    I’m always skeptical of a universal brow shade, but it sounds like a good one!

  9. Retrodiva says

    September 16, 2013 at 3:16 pm

    I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE Mario Badescu! My go-to skin care line.

  10. Brooke says

    September 16, 2013 at 5:10 pm

    This is such a great list. It’s wonderful to see so many of my fave brands with excellent CF items!

  11. Eugenia says

    September 16, 2013 at 6:46 pm

    I love me some Beautisol!! I will need it more now so I wont be so white in the winter!

  12. Brittany says

    September 17, 2013 at 8:28 am

    Heck yah to Lip Tars. My favorite lippies ever!!

  13. Rebecca Thrittle says

    September 17, 2013 at 8:45 am

    Ooooo has to be NCLA for me! Thanks for the list and thanks for sharing 🙂 xx

  14. beautybabbling says

    September 24, 2013 at 9:07 am

    Awww…not Mario Badescu too! *sigh* That makes me really sad. I just bought their Special Glycolic Cleansing Lotion too.

  15. Dianne Stankavich says

    October 10, 2013 at 6:51 am

    When I read item 10 for Mario Badescue, I realized I had just read a blog on their site. See below.

    ———
    Skin Care Questions and Answers About cruelty_free

    I am very interested in trying Mario Badescu products – However, I did not see anything on your site as to whether or not the products are tested on animals….Close Response
    (asked by Lynsey W.)

    At Mario Badescu, we use the finest ingredients in the formulation of our preparations since 1967. Mario Badescu does not test nor have we ever tested our products on animals. Our products are tested by our aestheticians and skin care consultants to ensure optimal product quality for our customers. We take this issue extremely seriously, and our committment is reflected on each and every page of skin care products in the No Animal Testing pledge in the lower left corner of the screen.

    Categories: Product Information
    Tags: all-natural | cruelty_free | no_animal_testing | safe_products

  16. chiefbunny says

    October 14, 2013 at 6:07 pm

    I don’t know how they can say they don’t test when they have a store in Shanghai China!

  17. S. says

    October 31, 2013 at 11:39 am

    Yes, MB is sold in China. Here’s the url for reference: http://mariobadescu.net/
    So disappointed.

  18. Karen says

    March 14, 2014 at 7:44 am

    Is there a good facial powder you recommend? I’ve been trying all kinds of cruely free products but so far they all turned out to be gunky. I use it after applying moisturizer so I’m not shiny all day. Do you know of anything that goes on smoothly and doesn’t create a “your face is full of powder” look?

  19. Jen Mathews says

    March 14, 2014 at 11:24 am

    Have you tried It Cosmetics or Youngblood?

  20. Karen says

    March 15, 2014 at 8:22 am

    Nope, are they any good? I don’t mind paying more for something of higher quality. I’m looking into Ecco Bella but I’m having trouble choosing the right color since it’s online. I’m pretty white, but I don’t always get the lightest color. I’ll look into It Cosmetics and Youngblood though – thanks for the recommendation. I still haven’t found a good one since I decided to move to cruelty free products so it’s been a while.

  21. straightwhitemale says

    June 12, 2014 at 12:00 am

    Do you have any suggestions for foundation? I have reeeeally pale skin and most stuff is too orange/yellow for me 🙁 I was thinking of trying Kat Von Ds foundations?

    I’m currently using Urban Decay naked which is alright coverage and is the only foundation that doesn’t make me break out but the coverage on the oily parts of my face gets so weird? Like it gets patchy after a while 🙁 Illamasqua made me break out like crazy and was too heavy.

    Ahhhhh it’s just really hard to find something half decent that matches all of my specifications (pale, cruelty free, doesn’t make me break out, preferably vegan, long lasting)

What is My Beauty Bunny?

My Beauty Bunny is an award-winning, top 10, cruelty free beauty, health, and lifestyle blog. We've been publishing cruelty free beauty reviews since 2009!

Top beauty blog, My Beauty Bunny, focuses on finding the best in beauty from companies who do not test on animals. We are not a vegan blog, but we do have a vegan section.

Founder & Cruelty Free Beauty Expert, Jen Mathews, is the President of social media and marketing agency, Top Tier Media. As seen in People Style Watch, Refinery 29, HuffPost Live, Shape Magazine, Fab Fit Fun, GQ, Teen Vogue and QVC. Founder of the Beauty Blog Coalition.

LOOKING FOR SOMETHING?

SUBSCRIBE TO MY BEAUTY BUNNY

Get the latest tips and reviews with your FREE My Beauty Bunny newsletter!

FOLLOW @MYBEAUTYBUNNY ON INSTAGRAM
  • Bloglovin
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2025 · MY BEAUTY BUNNY by MLL Design + Branding Studio

  • HOME ·
  • Cruelty Free Beauty Brands
  • Privacy Policy & Legal
  • News
  • About My Beauty Bunny