Many of you have heard rumors about brands entering China, which means I can no longer consider them to be cruelty free. Here is an up to date list, according to my sources. Some of these brands are still calling themselves “cruelty free” even though they are allowing third party testing. For those of you who have heard rumors about NYX, Tashina from Logical Harmony has contacted them and they are STILL cruelty free – so we’re keeping them on the good list!
List of Beauty Brands Selling in China (a country that REQUIRES animal testing)
Note: this information is obtained from several sources – including the brands’ representatives. If you believe any information to be in inaccurate, please let me know.
- American Beauty (EL)
- Aramis (EL)
- Avon
- Bobbi Brown (EL)
- Bumble and Bumble (EL)
- Caudalie
- Clinique (EL)
- Coach (EL)
- Darphin (EL)
- Donna Karan (EL)
- Ermenegildo Zegna (EL)
- Estee Lauder (EL)
- Flirt (EL)
- GoodSkin Labs (EL)
- Grassroots Research Labs (EL)
- Jo Malone (EL)
- Kiton (EL)
- La Mer (EL)
- Lab Series for Men (EL)
- L’Occitane
- MAC (EL)
- Mary Kay
- Michael Kors (EL)
- Missoni (EL)
- Ojon (EL)
- Origins (EL)
- Pangea Organics
- Prescriptives (EL)
- Revlon
- Sean John (EL)
Smashbox (EL)(See update here.)- Tom Ford (EL)
- Tommy Hilfiger (EL)
Urban Decay(Urban Decay has decided NOT to sell in China!)- Yves Rocher
EL = owned by Estee Lauder
Please see the most up to date cruelty free beauty brand list here!
Liz says
According to their Belgian/Dutch website, Yves Rocher doesn’t test on animals (http://www.yves-rocher.be/control/com/be/NL/duurzame_ontwikkeling/ethisch_verantwoorde_cosmetica/dierproefvrij/). I don’t know if this is true, I don’t know what to believe anymore.
Annabel says
god this makes me so angry! WHY test.. just WHY?! UGH
Thank god clarins and REN aren’t on that list or I’d cry.
makeup monster says
Fantastic article, it’s great to have a list that definitely do
Sara says
I just noticed that even though products might say “People-Tested” it doesn’t mean that it ONLY tested on humans. tricky tricky
Moxie says
Makes me sick. I’ll keep RT your post!
Val Bury says
I am very surprised to see in your list that Mary Kay Cosmetics is a third-party to animal testing in China. I would hope that Mary Kay will either confirm this or rebute this article. As they have listed they do NOT do animal testing on their products nor use any animal byproducts in their cosmetics!
Steelnpurple says
Thank you for the updated list! <3
SO glad to hear about NYX! I just recently bought two of their tinted lip balms and was so bummed to hear the rumor right after I had ordered them!
Thanks!
Holly Petrie says
But don’t bother posting or questioning them on their Facebook pages. They apparently employ people full time just to delete any comments that they don’t like!
Gayle Carbajal says
I’m really surprised to see Pangea Organics on that list. Pangea confirmed? How awful!
Kath says
Thanks for sharing. I favorited this post for reference.
Tracy J says
Thanks for the update, Jen! Also, while I realize your reviews are for more high-end brands, I recently, and accidentally, discovered that discount brand L.A. Colors is cruelty free (unless that status has changed, too). The line may be a dollar store staple, but as product junkie on an extreme budget, I was rather impressed with their mascara and nail lacquers – it’s no OPI or Zoya, but for 99 cents per bottle, I can now afford to play with gradients, rainbows and the like. >^.^<
Emma RZ says
So disappointed about Caudalie 🙁
Beth Br00tality says
There are several missing from this list. =[
chiefbunny says
Beth – this wasn’t meant to be a comprehensive list of brands that test on animals – for that you can visit the PETA website. If you have evidence that other brands have recently entered China, please let me know – jen at mybeautybunny dot com – Thanks!
chiefbunny says
Hi Tracy – thanks for the update! We try to review drugstore brands too – like Milani, Wet N Wild, Revlon, etc. I bought an LA Colors liquid eyeliner at an IMATS show a couple years back and I wasn’t really impressed. But I haven’t tried the nail polish. Will have to give that a shot! 🙂
chiefbunny says
Hi Val – there are several companies on this list who are doing business in China (which requires animal testing) but are still claiming innocence since they don’t do the actual testing – but 3rd party testing is still testing.
chiefbunny says
Hi Liz – there are several brands who still maintain their cruelty free statuses – despite 3rd party testing in China. There’s actually a class action lawsuit against Estee Lauder for this reason.
Clinique Coupons says
I saw Clinique on the list. Animal testing is so wrong.
pat dupree says
there goes my estee lauder, mary kay and clinique. good riddance.
i have informed the mary kay supplier and told her i was looking a pic of 10 trusting bunnies with their head in a vise. and a beagle puppy.
cry and pray for an end. and respond to divine intervention and human effort web sites like this. thank you my beauty bunny.
pray and think what to do. pray and think what to do.
Amanda Spears says
Thank you for the updated list!
Amanda says
I work for an AVEDA Salon, and I called around. AVEDA does not sell in China and has no plans too. Please remove them from this list.
chiefbunny says
Hi Amanda, I SO wish Aveda could be considered cruelty free, because I love the brand, but unfortunately they are owned by Estee Lauder and I it is my understanding that they are being sold in China. Their public stance on animal testing has changed from “no animal testing” to “no animal testing except where required by law” which usually means a brand is selling in a country that requires it (like China) or a country where it is common practice (like Brazil).
Kelinci Hias says
Thanks for sharing. I’ll keep RT your post!
Isabel says
I am using MAC. They said they do not test on animals. I guess they are lying? What great foundation makeup is cruelty free? Thankyou
DawnW says
Don’t forget that now Urban Decay is owned by L’Oreal,animal testers.So disappointing.
chiefbunny says
They probably aren’t lying – depending on who you talk to, they may not know. The employees at the store level usually have no idea that the products are being sold in China (a country that requires animal testing). For a cruelty foundation, try Youngblood, Too Faced or Stila.
Free Coupon says
Its really nice blog. I think this blog is very helpful to us. I suggest everyone to visit this
blog because we can get very important information from this blog. I will visite this blog
regular and I suggest everyone to visit this blog
regularly.
Sabrina says
PETA website article: China to Approve First Non-Animal Cosmetics Test
http://www.peta.org/b/thepetafiles/archive/2012/05/07/china-to-approve-first-non-animal-cosmetics-test.aspx
My Beauty Bunny, what do you all know about this? Thanks!
chiefbunny says
I did see that! Thanks for sharing! 🙂
Hari says
Great post dear! You really posted a great article and it will help all the person. Who are wanting help form someone. Your information is very helpful.
Thanks for writing these type of article.
Ramy says
Great One.. I found i so useful .. Keep going . I Also write about IT in my Own blog .. Search You Are Such A computer Guy
Rashmi says
I’m still confused about Aveda. Todays I pulled the PETA list of companies that don’t test on animals and Aveda is on that list with “L” indicating that the company has an licensed PETA s official bunny-free cruelty logo.
chiefbunny says
Hi Rashmi – from what I understand, Aveda is one of the only companies that is owned by EL, but not currently sold in China. However, they do use an “except where required by law” notice, which means they could enter the Chinese (or Brazilian) markets at any time. It’s unclear and vague, so I’m avoiding them for now.
Kelly Davis says
Chief bunny,
Hello! Any update on your Aveda verdict since August? Are they selling in China or Brazil yet?
Thanks for all of your research!
chiefbunny says
Kelly – I would avoid Aveda. They have “except where required by law” statement which is never a good sign!
JY says
I have seen both Clarins and Jurlique now being sold in China. This is seen by my own eyes.
Jen Mathews says
Yes – Clarins and Jurlique are no longer CF.
LACY says
URBAN DECAY HAS DECIDED TO SELL IN CHINA ACCORDING TO THEIR FACEBOOK POST!
Jen Mathews says
No – they have stayed out of China.
MizzMo says
They DON’T test. EL would lose them if they did – part of the agreement with Horst when it was sold. This is also why Horst’s kids are still part of Aveda 🙂
Alexi Frest says
Hi Beauty Bunny,
I want a spiral perm that is animal friendly or possibly vegan. I live in Hungary, Europe. Europe has already banned animal testing. Does it mean that perm materials are animal friendly?
kendisi says
Great list! I was surprised to see Pangea Organics and I searched to see that they actually stopped selling in China (link: http://www.peta.org/blog/pangea-organics-stops-selling-china/). According to the FAQ on their website:
*Pangea Organics is registered with caringconsumer.org (run by PETA) as a cruelty-free company (we never test on animals).
Jen Mathews says
I’m not sure about that Alexi – the best thing to do is to contact the brand and ask if they are selling in China. Europe does allow a loophole for brands to sell in China.
Vicki says
Does Avon use animal testing when selling to China?
chiefbunny says
Correct – Avon is NOT cruelty free anymore.
Mandy says
They have no choice, ANY cosmetic sold in China MUST by Chinese law be tested on animals.
Mandy says
PETA are not overly reliable, they list companies which do sell in China (and therefore are not cruelty free) they also list companies who are owned by animal testing parent companies (eg L’Oreal owns the Body Shop and Urban Decay, therefore when you buy from either of them you’re giving money to L’Oreal who test on animals). PETA also list companies who have buy raw ingredients which have been tested on animals by a third party. My advice is to use The Leaping Bunny or Choose Cruelty Free (if in Australia or New Zealand) because their a lot more strict on who they will list. Choose Cruelty Free de-listed The Body Shop because L’Oreal owns them.
Mandy says
If in doubt DON’T buy a cosmetic, there are plenty of brands around which are cruelty free you just need to hunt a bit. There’s a great ‘drug store’ brand in Australia called Face of Australia, they’re cruelty free (as listed by Choose Cruelty Free), of high quality and not overly expensive. It just takes some dedication.
Gia says
Hi! Just to let you know, Clarins sells to China… =( So disappointed.
Darlene Veg An says
“Urban Decay has decided NOT to sell in China”
But Urban Decay is now owned by L’oreal, which tests on animals and has been secretly fighting against the ban of animal testing while telling their customers that they are doing their best to end animal testing.
Learn more:
– http://www.theguardian.com/world/2003/aug/19/eu.businessofresearch
– http://www.facebook.com/notes/the-bloody-dairy-industry/vegan-household-cosmetic-products/497961893643687
Mary says
Hi Jen, I’m really confused over smashbox. It’s on your list of cosmetics selling in China, but Phyrra says it’s cruelty free as it doesn’t sell in China.
Jen Mathews says
Hi Mary – Smashbox is selling in China. They are not cruelty free.
HazelNut says
Hi! I’m a bit confused over smashbox as well. Their website specifically says they don’t sell in China but I’m getting conflicting information here and elsewhere. Can you please shed some light on this? Thank you kindly 🙂
Sandra Kirchberger says
interesting information…so maybe then it is safe to say that Aveda will not be testing on animals then. Thanks for the info=)
jennifer says
maybelline, loreal,covergirl are not on this list
chiefbunny says
Maybelline, L’Oreal and Cover Girl are NOT cruelty free.
Julie Firth says
I’ve seen La colors on the non cruelty list, but I recently bought eyeshadows from them and they were made in China. I am so disappointed!
chiefbunny says
Hi Julie – I haven’t heard any change in LA Colors’ CF status, but I will tell you that being made in China has no impact on whether a product is cruelty free. Many products are made in China but not SOLD in China. If they products are sold in mainland China (Hong Kong is an exception), then in most cases, they have to be tested on animals (per the Chinese gov’t).
Julie Firth says
Oh, I see. Thank you so much for the clarification. This whole thing really is a bit confusing. But I am relieved that being made in China does not necessarily mean that they are sold in China. Thanks again!
Anonimous says
Interesting readin. What about Clarins? This brand is not on the list but I am sure I saw Clarins products for sale in Beijing. By Chinese law Clarins’ products must be tested on animals otherwise they would not be able to sell it in China. Do u have any further info on this please.
chiefbunny says
Clarins is not cruelty free.
Natalie says
Hello! Does anyone have a list of CRUELTY FREE beauty brands that are sold in china??? Or websites that can be accessed from china for shipping??? Will be moving there soon for work…
Karen Martin says
Young Blood Minetal Cosmetics has a distributer in China. So they are not cruelty free.
chiefbunny says
I just reached out to Youngblood and had Tashina from Logical Harmony reached out as well. They told us they are only in Hong Kong (where animal testing is not required).
Maggie says
According to China low EVERY beauty product sell in this country (china) need to be animal tested. If company said they don’t do it, but you can find they’re product to buy in China THEY LIE. If they’re only made product there but don’t sell then it maybe aren’t tested. Other wise, sorry 😉
Michael Pham says
smashbox no longer sells in China, and they’ve included PETA’s bunny logo on their products too. they don’t test where required by law 🙂
chiefbunny says
Yes Smashbox is CF – see my updated article with all the details! https://mybeautybunny.com/is-smashbox-cruelty-free/