• HOME
  • CRUELTY FREE RESOURCES
    • Cruelty Free Beauty Brands
    • Cruelty Free Brands at Sephora
    • Cruelty Free Questions to Ask Brands
    • News
  • About
    • About My Beauty Bunny
    • Privacy Policy & Legal
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube

My Beauty Bunny - Cruelty Free Lifestyle Blog

  • Hair
  • Health
  • Lifestyle
  • Makeup
  • Misc
    • Budget
    • Dupes
    • Fashion
    • Giveaways
    • Leaping Bunny
    • Men
  • Nails
  • News
  • Pets
  • Skin
    • Body
    • Acne-prone
    • Combination Skin
    • Dry Skin
    • Oily Skin
    • Salons
  • Travel
  • Vegan

Stay up to date with all our latest posts!

You are here: Home / Misc / Budget / What is the Last Product You Wanted to Love But Didn’t?

What is the Last Product You Wanted to Love But Didn’t?

in Budget, Lifestyle, Makeup, Misc on 09/10/18

PR Sample

Milani Lip Creme Soulmate Amore Shine Metallic Red Lipstick | What is the Last Product You Wanted to Love But Didn't? featured by popular Los Angeles cruelty free beauty blogger My Beauty Bunny

Question of the Week: Name the last product you REALLY wanted to love, but didn’t.

 Milani Lip Creme:

Yesterday I went to Mama Shelter, a popular rooftop bar in Hollywood, to celebrate my friend Katie’s birthday. I wanted to glam it up a little bit, and I had just received a sample of Amore Matte Metallic Milani Lip Creme in “My Soulmate”, so this seemed like a good time to do a wear test. First of all let me say, the color is BEAUTIFUL and I’m not sure this photo does it justice. I got tons of compliments on it, from my friends, and especially from Gregg, who kept telling me how much he loved it!

Milani Lip Creme Soulmate Amore Shine Metallic Red Lipstick | What is the Last Product You Wanted to Love But Didn't? featured by popular Los Angeles cruelty free beauty blogger My Beauty Bunny

I wanted to love it too, but unfortunately, it would NOT stay in the center of my lips. It immediately started to flake off on the car ride over to the bar. I added some more, and noticed it looked jagged and flaky, so I just went with it. Then of course, once I started eating and drinking, it REALLY came off, and unfortunately I had to put a creamier lipstick on top of it to cover everything. I was really disappointed because I love Milani, the price is right (about $9) and this color was SO good!

I didn’t have any issues with the regular Milani Lip Creme Amore Shine lipsticks, so I think it’s either just the metallics, or just that particular shade that doesn’t work for me. You can see some of my cruelty free Milani lipstick swatches here.

I’m curious if any of you have tried this formula, and if it worked for you? What other products have you tried lately that you really wanted to love, but didn’t?

The Lipstick League – week of 9.3.18

Please note that not all Lipstick League posts are cruelty free.

Blushing Noir – Fall is the best time for new makeup, especially for eyes! Check out some of my Fall drugstore beauty favorites from Maybelline.

My Beauty Bunny – knows why your acne is not going away despite that crazy expensive skincare regimen you’ve been using. Click through for life-changing skin tips!

Phyrra – Stuck in a makeup rut? Check out these 15+ Urban Decay Aphrodisiac Palette Tutorials and Looks for Inspiration. They’re perfect for Fall!

Slashed Beauty – Ready to rock some braided hairstyles for fall? Watch this hair tutorial for four braided hairstyles to try out this season.

we heart this – We all know Probiotics are good for your insides. But did you know they’re good for your outside too? Meet Tula Skincare.

Beautygeeks – has all the details on Shellac Luxe, CND’s newest UV polish that needs no base coat and soaks off in an easy, speedy 60 seconds.

(Wondering what the Lipstick League is? Find out here.)

Blushing Noir is Currently Craving: The Benefit Brow Contour Pro. I have a lot of sparse areas in my brows and I think a product like this with 2 brow shades plus a definer and highlighter is exactly what I’ve been looking for my whole adult life.

About Jen Mathews

Jen Mathews is the Chief Bunny and social media maestro for My Beauty Bunny. She is also the President of Top Tier Media, a digital marketing agency for beauty, fashion, health and lifestyle brands. Follow My Beauty Bunny on Instagram for more cruelty free goodness!

FOLLOW MY BEAUTY BUNNY ON SOCIAL:
       
 

SUBSCRIBE TO MY BEAUTY BUNNY

Get the latest on cruelty-free beauty with your FREE My Beauty Bunny newsletter!

« Top 10 Places to Visit in London
Lamora – Did I Just Find a Beauty Blender Dupe? »

Comments

  1. Evana says

    September 10, 2018 at 8:34 am

    Vince Camuto Bella perfume

  2. Gabrielle says

    September 10, 2018 at 9:40 am

    I wanted to adore Fenty Gloss Bomb Universal Lip Luminizer, but, like most things that are said to be perfect for EVERYONE, it looked like hell on me. I should have learned my lesson from the “looks on amazing on everyone” Nars Orgasm Blush, which made me look like I had a disease, that I will always be the exception. *sigh*

  3. chiefbunny says

    September 12, 2018 at 6:07 pm

    Yeah Orgasm never looked right on me either! I had to give up on NARS when they started selling in China anyway. 🙁

What is My Beauty Bunny?

My Beauty Bunny is an award-winning, top 10, cruelty free beauty, health, and lifestyle blog. We've been publishing cruelty free beauty reviews since 2009!

Top beauty blog, My Beauty Bunny, focuses on finding the best in beauty from companies who do not test on animals. We are not a vegan blog, but we do have a vegan section.

Founder & Cruelty Free Beauty Expert, Jen Mathews, is the President of social media and marketing agency, Top Tier Media. As seen in People Style Watch, Refinery 29, HuffPost Live, Shape Magazine, Fab Fit Fun, GQ, Teen Vogue and QVC. Founder of the Beauty Blog Coalition.

LOOKING FOR SOMETHING?

SUBSCRIBE TO MY BEAUTY BUNNY

Get the latest tips and reviews with your FREE My Beauty Bunny newsletter!

FOLLOW @MYBEAUTYBUNNY ON INSTAGRAM
  • Bloglovin
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2025 · MY BEAUTY BUNNY by MLL Design + Branding Studio

  • HOME ·
  • Cruelty Free Beauty Brands
  • Privacy Policy & Legal
  • News
  • About My Beauty Bunny